Latvian PM slams OSCE
official on language rights
Reuters World Report Thursday, March 21, 2002
11:09:00 AM Copyright 2002 Reuters Ltd. By Burton Frierson
RIGA, March 21 (Reuters) --
Latvia on Thursday called for the resignation of a senior official from a top
European security and human rights group for suggesting the ex-Soviet country
make Russian an official second language.
During a visit to the Baltic state on
Wednesday Gerard Stoudmann, a senior Organisation for Security and Cooperation
in Europe (OSCE) official, told local journalists Russian was already "de facto
the second language." "I think that it
would be logical to confirm that it has an official status," Stoudmann was
quoted as saying in English by Radio Free Europe. Other media ran similar
quotes. Latvia has been urged to
liberalise legislation affecting Russians here -- around a third of the 2.4
million population -- by NATO and the EU, both of which it hopes to join.
But language is an extremely sensitive
issue for Latvia, which emerged from five decades of Russian-dominated Soviet
rule in 1991, and sees independence and the predominance of Latvian in public
life as inextricably connected. Current
EU president Spain does not have an embassy in Riga, and the Danish embassy,
speaking for the presidency, issued a statement to clarify Brussels' position.
This said the OSCE -- which it looked to as a key arbiter of human rights --
had never questioned Latvia's "sovereign right to decide itself about its state
language." "There is no expectation
whatsoever on (the) part of the European Union that Latvia should change or
amend the provision that establishes that the Latvian language is the state
language of Latvia," the embassy said in a statement.
Stoudmann's comments drew strong
reaction from Prime Minister Andris Berzins, who has been trying to build
support for liberalising the election law -- which requires all candidates to
prove they can speak Latvian well.
"Stoudmann should resign," Berzins'
press office said in a statement. Stoudmann was expected to issue a statement
later. Stoudmann, the Swiss head of the
OSCE's office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights, had made his
original comment on the sidelines of a conference on the OSCE's role in shaping
Latvian policy toward its Russians.
NATO has indicated that changes in the
election law are needed to help Latvia's bid to join the alliance in November.
But, with a general election due by
October many politicians are reluctant to alter it, fearful of angering
nationalist voters. The changes could
fall through completely if lawmakers think the West will demand Russian be
given official status. After
independence, Latvian was made the state language, marginalising many
Russian-speakers, who also fell foul of strict rules on who could become
citizens of Latvia.
Latvia calls to sack
OSCE official for backing Russian as second language
COMTEX Newswire Thursday, March 21, 2002 5:00:00
PM Copyright 2002 ITAR-TASS
RIGA, Mar 21, 2002 (Itar-Tass via
COMTEX) -- Latvian authorities demanded to sack a high-ranking official of
the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) who proposed
that Russian should become the second official language in the Baltic republic.
Gerard Studman, the director of the
OSCE Bureau for democratic institutions and human rights, told reporters on
Wednesday that Russian was "de facto the second language" in Latvia.
"Studman must resign", the press
service of Prime Minister Andris Berzins commented on Thursday.
Russian speakers comprise a third of
the Latvian population.
Statoil buys Shell
Baltic petrol stations
Reuters Financial Report Friday, March 22, 2002
3:22:00 AM Copyright 2002 Reuters Ltd.
OSLO, March 22 (Reuters) --
Norwegian state-controlled oil company Statoil said on Friday that it was
buying Shell's service stations in the Baltic states.
It did not give a price of the deal
with the Royal Dutch/Shell group. "The
acquisition, which is conditional on the approval of the authorities in the
respective coutnries, includes 61 service stations in all, 26 in Estonia, 19 in
Latvia and 16 in Lithuania," it said in a statement.
Statoil currently runs about 90 of its
own petrol stations in the Baltic states unmder the brand name 1-2-3.
Poland, Baltic states
to work together to ensure Baltic membership in NATO
AP WorldStream Friday, March 22, 2002 11:06:00
AM Copyright 2002 The Associated Press By LIUDAS DAPKUS Associated
Press Writer
VILNIUS, Lithuania (AP) -- NATO
candidate countries Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia said Friday that they'll draw
on the experience and connections of current member Poland in a final push to
enter the powerful alliance. At a
one-day summit in Vilnius, Lithuania's capital, the Baltic and Polish
presidents announced plans to form a working group made up of their respective
U.S.-based ambassadors that would coordinate Baltic lobbying.
The three ex-Soviet republics are among
nine countries hoping to win coveted invitations to join the U.S.-led alliance,
which is expected to launch another round of expansion eastward during a summit
this November in Prague, the Czech Republic.
Lithuanian President Valdas Adamkus
said the Polish Embassy in Washington would provide key guidance as Baltic
diplomats make their case in the U.S. capital.
Poland, which borders Lithuania to the
south, joined NATO in 1999 along with Hungary and the Czech Republic. It also
spent years lobbying NATO states, some of which appeared skeptical about the
benefits of taking in new members.
Adamkus was joined at the Vilnius
summit by Polish President Alexander Kwasniewski, Estonian President Arnold
Ruutel and Latvian President Vaira Vike-Freiberga.
Despite Kremlin opposition to Baltic
membership -- which neighboring Russia perceives as a threat -- the Baltics are
seen as having good chances of landing invitations. The 19-member alliance,
though, has made no promises.
Kwasniewski repeated Poland's backing
for Baltic aspirations. "The decision
to enlarge NATO would be historical in that it would abolish the consequences
and lines of World War II," he said at a joint news conference.
The Red Army occupied the three Baltic
countries in 1940 after the Soviet Union and Germany divided Europe into so
called spheres of influence. They only regained independence during the 1991
Soviet collapse. Latvia's president
expressed confidence the three Baltics, with Poland's help, would woo NATO,
adding that "I hope all four of us can open a bottle of champagne in Prague to
celebrate victory."
Moscow criticizes
Russian language situation in Latvia
COMTEX Newswire Friday, March 22, 2002 3:54:00
PM Copyright 2002 ITAR-TASS By Irina Shatalova
MOSCOW, Mar 22, 2002 (Itar-Tass via
COMTEX) -- The situation with the Russian language in Latvia runs counter
to the related laws of Europe, says a report of the Russian Foreign Ministry
obtained by Itar-Tass. The ministry
comments on the Latvian negative reaction to the pronouncements of the Director
of the OSCE Bureau for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights that Russian
should obtain the official status in Latvia.
The reaction "highlighted the essence
of the problem the Russian minorities faces in that country," the report runs.
"By insisting on only one state
language, Latvian, the authorities of Latvia do not wish to reckon with the
legitimate rights of the numerous Russian-speaking minority to use the native
tongue in compliance with the European standards," the report stresses. "It is
a fact that the Russian language still does not have the official status of a
minority tongue in Latvia, and the Law on State Language describes Russian as a
foreign language with all the related consequences."
The denial of internationally
recognized rights to people, in particular "on historical reasons," runs
counter to the European Convention on Human Rights and a number of other
legislative acts, the report says. "The
experience of several East European countries, which have drafted laws with the
assistance of European experts to give language minorities the right to the
official use of their native language at least in the areas of their compact
residence, suggests a way of a legal solution to the problem, " the ministry
remarks. "The obvious unwillingness of
the authorities to bring the Latvian legislation in conformity to the
international commitments makes one think about the real value of Riga's
statements on its wish to promote the integration of the Latvian society," the
report emphasizes.
Feature --
Linguistic pride proves NATO problem for Latvia
Reuters World Report Sunday, March 24, 2002
9:07:00 PM Copyright 2002 Reuters Ltd. By Burton Frierson
RIGA, March 25 (Reuters) -- In
1997 school teacher Antonina Ignatane came just one vote short in her bid to
win a seat on the city council of Latvia's capital, Riga.
What galled her was that the crucial
vote wasn't placed in a ballot box but cast long before election day by a state
official who decided Ignatane -- whose native tongue is Russian -- did not
speak Latvian well enough to run for public office.
Indignant, she and her Equality Party,
popular among members of the country's large Russian-speaking minority, went to
court. "If there is a certain
electorate that proposes me or someone else, how can somebody else take that
person off the list or decide whether he can run or not?" said Ignatane, a
German teacher since 1960. Under
Latvia's election law, they can. It
requires all candidates for political office to demonstrate they can speak
top-notch Latvian. The demand was meant to protect the Latvian language, which
was marginalised under 50 years of Russian-dominated Soviet occupation.
Human rights experts say the law
violates the rights of Russian speakers, one-third of the population, and that
the requirement has been open to abuse and corruption.
The law has become an obstacle to
Latvia's bid to join NATO, which Riga sees as the best guarantee of the
independence it regained in 1991. And
time is running out to change it. NATO,
which wants aspirants to resolve potential minority conflicts before joining,
meets in November in Prague to decide which of nine applicants will get
invitations to become a member. Apart
from its election law, Latvia, with 2.4 million people, is a top candidate.
Fellow Baltic states Lithuania and Estonia are also favourites and neighbouring
Russia has softened its opposition to ex-Soviet states entering NATO.
Lawmakers are struggling to resolve the
issue but politicians, facing elections in October, fear looking weak on
language -- a sensitive issue for a country that emerged 10 years ago from five
decades of Russification.
REQUIREMENT
DEBATED What made Ignatane's
case worse was that she had passed a state test and got language credentials
required for political candidates weeks before the snap visit of an inspector.
After a trip to Latvia's Supreme Court,
and intervention by the U.N. Human Rights Committee, Latvia last year abolished
the "language hunts" but left the language requirement in the law.
In February, NATO Secretary General
George Robertson told Latvia's parliament the outcome of lawmakers' debate on
the law would play an important role in the decision on membership.
"There's a good chance, a real good
chance this issue could keep us out," said a government source. "A few months
ago I could have seen Latvia getting an invite without changing the law and
then having to do it later. Now I'm not so sure."
NERVOUS ABOUT NATO
Robertson's speech may also have
allayed some worries on the part of Latvia's Russian speakers about joining
NATO, the Cold War enemy of Moscow and the Russian-speaking world.
"NATO is doing the right thing," said
61-year-old Vladimir, a car park attendant who served in the Soviet army.
Polls show Russians here oppose NATO
entry. Many fear being caught between two ex-rivals would hurt economic
prospects. "Latvia should keep its
neutrality, then it will have no problems with the West or Russia," said
Vladimir, who, like many in here doesn't want to give a last name when talking
politics. A survey conducted in
December showed 27 percent of Russian speakers supported NATO entry, compared
to 66 percent of Latvians. SHORT
ON TIME FOR LONG DEBATE There
is probably nothing more central to Latvians' sense of independence than their
language. With Lithuanian, it is one of two surviving Baltic languages.
Together with Estonian, a Finno-Ugric language, they form a linguistic outpost
in a region dominated by Slavic tongues.
Lawmakers are considering a package of
constitutional changes to further strengthen the status of Latvian in an
attempt to make amending the election law easier to swallow, but the political
atmosphere surrounding the issue is tense.
On March 21, Latvian Prime Minister
Andris Berzins called for the resignation of an official from the Organisation
for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) for suggesting the country make
Russian an official second language.
The official later said his "personal
reflection on the issue" had been misinterpreted and that neither he nor the
OSCE -- a key arbiter of rights
standards for NATO and the EU -- questioned the status of Latvian as the only
state language. But the incident showed
the thin line Berzins must walk to protect Latvian and also get the election
law amended. Legal changes could fall through completely if lawmakers thought
the West would demand Russian be given official status.
"This is quite controversial and it has
to be done very, very slowly and people have to be made sure that the language
is safe," said Kristiana Libane, an MP pushing for the changes.
Latvians preserved their language
throughout centuries of domination by Germans, Poles, Swedes and Russians.
At the end of the Soviet occupation --
[during which] Russians were given incentives to move to the Baltic state,
while Latvians were deported to camps in Siberia -- Russian-language shop and
street signs were torn down and a Latvian revival began.
Latvia adopted laws on citizenship,
language and elections that included measures to protect Latvian, making it the
state language, and put up barriers to non-Latvians becoming citizens.
BUILDING TOLERANCE
Hardliners will not support amendments
scrapping the language requirement, but others are wavering and may come round
if voters' fears over the language can be assuaged.
Those pushing the changes are hoping
tolerance will prevail among people like Dzintra Jatniece, a 63-year-old
cleaning lady. Deported to Siberia with her family when as a child, she says
she would choose NATO entry over sticking to the election law.
"Russian-speakers should learn Latvian,
no doubt about that, but there should be no compulsion. Deported Latvians were
forced to learn the (Russian) language," she said.
Latvian President Vaira Vike-Freiberga,
herself a scholar of Latvian culture, has said it is wrong to try to protect
the language with an election law, a process which she calls "mixing sauerkraut
and fruit syrup." The current law was
just discriminatory, she said. "It is
in stark contradiction to what our constitution says that all citizens have the
right to elect and run for a post."
Latvia presses for
inclusion in NATO "security umbrella"
AP WorldStream Wednesday, March 27, 2002 9:33:00
AM Copyright 2002 The Associated Press
ATHENS, Greece (AP) -- The NATO
"security umbrella" is vital for Latvia and the tiny Baltic nation is prepared
to offer support for missions by the Western alliance, Latvia's president said
Wednesday. Latvia, a former Soviet
republic, is pressing hard for membership in NATO. It also is expected to be in
the first group of new European Union members when the EU expands eastward.
"NATO's security umbrella is extremely
important to Latvia," said Latvian President Vaira Vike-Freiberga after meeting
with Greek Premier Costas Simitis. "We
are in a geographical location that has been the cause of periods of occupation
and aggression coming from larger countries ... For us it's particularly
important to be included in the NATO alliance," she added.
Vike-Freiberga also stressed that
Latvia, which has contributed troops to peacekeeping operations in the Balkans,
wants "to be partners in an alliance where we are fully committed to be
contributors of defense, not just consumers of defense."
Delegations from Latvia and Greece
signed a series of agreements which included naval cooperation and the
avoidance of double taxation.
NATO-member Greece will hold the EU's
six-month rotating presidency for the first half of 2003, when agreements for
candidate countries' accession could be signed.
Lithuania needs three
billion euros to shut down nuclear plant
COMTEX Newswire Friday, March 29, 2002 6:54:00
AM Copyright 2002 ITAR-TASS
LONDON, Mar 29, 2002 (Itar-Tass via
COMTEX) -- President of Lithuania Valdas Adamkus has asked the European
Union to allocate three billion euros in order to shut down the Ignalin nuclear
power station. Adamkus has notified British Prime Minister Tony Blair about
Vilnius' position. During a meeting
between Adamkus and Blair in London on Thursday, a demand was voiced addressed
to the Euroepean Union to finance the operation of shutting down the second
reactor of the Ignalin nuclear power station.
If the first reactor might be shut down
by 2005 in return for guaranteed accession of Lithuania to the European Union,
the second reactor, which has recently been overhauled by Sweden, meets all the
existing safety standards, Adamkus said. Therefore, the problem of shutting
down the second reactor in 2009 depends, entirely, on EU financial
possibilities, Adamkus said. London has
brought to the notice of the Lithuanian officials the position assumed by the
European Union that the Ignalin nuclear power station should be shut down.
Nevertheless, Adamkus declared that Lithuania has no funds of its own to shut
down the second reactor. In mid-March,
the European Commission had reproached Vilnius for reluctance to carry on a
dialogue, warning that it might become a serious obstacle to Lithuania's
admission to the European Union. |